Facing the Climate Crisis with Open Hearts and Resilient Spirits

The Rev. Rob Hardies co-facilitated Nature|Spirit|Art with Dr. Joshua Shannon, Professor of Contemporary Art History at the University of Maryland. Rob is a Unitarian Universalist preacher, teacher and activist. From 2001 to 2020 he was senior minister of All Souls Church in Washington.

My heart is moved by all I cannot save: so much has been destroyed. I have to cast my lot with those who age after age, perversely, with no extraordinary power, reconstitute the world.

I returned often to these words by the poet Adrienne Rich during the recent Phillips workshop, Nature|Spirit|Art: Personal Resilience in the time of Climate Change. In the workshop, we used meditation, small group discussion, and creating and looking at art to explore practices that can keep us resilient and engaged as we face the climate crisis.

Workshop participants reflect on their experiences during the last session of Nature|Spirit|Art

Rich’s words touch on two such practices: acknowledging and grieving our climate loss, and committing to collective climate action. As Rich suggests, these practices are not unrelated: When we acknowledge and tend to it, our grief can lead us into compassionate connection with the Earth and with others, creating bonds of solidarity and common cause for action. At the Phillips, we considered the link between grief and collective action by studying and contemplating Jacob Lawrence’s Migration Series.

Grief, of course, is the flip-side of love. Our climate grief points us back to our love and gratitude for life on Earth. Finding ways to stay connected to our gratitude is another critical resilience practice. A highlight of the workshop for me was when we took a slow, meditative walk through the Phillips’ neighborhood. A storm had just passed through and everything glistened with fallen rain; the air was alive with that post-storm freshness. Some passers-by found my slow pace and curious gaze puzzling, but the walk helped me see with grateful new eyes a neighborhood I’ve called home for more than twenty years.

Workshop participant Joe’s self-portrait, taken during a rainy walk and inspired by Sam Taylor-Johnson’s Self-Portrait as a Tree, 2000

In the end, open-heartedness emerged for me as the overarching theme of our workshop. The enormity of the climate crisis threatens to isolate and paralyze us. But if we keep our hearts open to our grief, love, and gratitude, then we can remain resilient and engaged as we struggle on behalf of life on Earth.

Meet Our Chief Curator Elsa Smithgall

Meet our new Chief Curator Elsa Smithgall—who has been part of the Phillips’s curatorial team for 26 years—and hear about her goals for the department.

Elsa Smithgall in front of Airshaft (2021) by Nekisha Durrett. Photo: AK Blythe.

You have been at The Phillips Collection for 26 years. How do you think the Phillips has changed since then? How has the curatorial field changed since then?

The Phillips has indeed changed since I started more than two decades ago. One major change was structural: a major 30,000-square-foot addition in 2006. The new Sant Building created exciting opportunities, including additional galleries for the display of art as well as our first auditorium. Aside from this physical change, some of the most transformational organizational change I’ve witnessed occurred in the past few years in the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder and demands for racial justice. This global racial reckoning has catalyzed museums to center their work on diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility. Since our first chief diversity officer came on board in 2018, I have felt the impact of our DEAI initiatives; yet much important work remains. For curatorial, this has led to more interdepartmental collaboration with colleagues as well as with a diverse array of community partners. For example, the Phillips shaped its centennial exhibitions last year in collaboration with a community advisory group while also incorporating community voices in its collection catalogue and wall labels, both models for future projects grounded in a community-centered museum practice.

How will you continue the foundational mission of the museum?

The Phillips was born from our founder’s belief in the necessity of art to promote well-being and connection. That fundamentally remains at the heart of curatorial’s mission: to present, study, and make art accessible to all people, with empathy and inclusion. Today, the museum not only welcomes physical visitors from around the world but also virtual ones, bringing art beyond the walls of its original home at Dupont Circle and our satellite campus in Southeast DC.

Also important, Duncan Phillips aspired for his museum to be a “beneficent force in the community” and had a long history of supporting local living artists. Our latest centennial artist commissions by DC artists Wesley Clark, Nekisha Durrett, Victor Ekpuk, along with last year’s juried invitational for artists of the DC region are just some examples of the ways we seek to play an active role in supporting DC’s vibrant art scene.

Elsa Smithgall with jurors of juried invitational Inside Outside Upside Down.

What are your top priorities as Chief Curator?

In 2020, the museum developed a 5-year strategic and operating plan. As chief curator, my top priorities are to achieve outcomes that advance key strategic initiatives. Some highlights include:

  1. Build a strong, high-performing curatorial team in a culture of collaboration, belonging, empathy, innovation, and experimentation.
  2. Grow the collection by adding works that reflect the diversity of our communities and give voice to marginalized figures.
  3. Stimulate new research and fresh perspectives on our collection that allow us to tell more expansive, inclusive stories about our cultural histories.
  4. Deepen authentic collaboration with community and academic partners in co-shaping exhibitions, programs, and initiatives.
  5. Craft a dynamic, innovative exhibition program that supports diverse artistic expressions and invites dialogue about the pressing issues of our day.
  6. Leverage digital technologies to strengthen visitor engagement through digital storytelling, interactive participation, and online publications.

What is one of your favorite works in the collection that many people may not know about?

There are many, but one I would call out is our gouache by Gwendolyn Knight that she painted during a visit to New Orleans in 1941, following her marriage to Jacob Lawrence. It showcases Knight’s artistic talents in color and design. What I love is the way Knight juxtaposes the larger-than-life red and green blossoming banana flower with the cool geometric buildings, windows, and stairwell and a glistening azure sky. Then upon closer look one notices a silhouetted figure in a red dress cradled beneath the flower. Might that figure represent the artist? Where will her next step take her?

Elsa Smithgall with Roger Sant at the opening of Bonnard to Vuillard. Photo: Rhiannon Newman.

What other favorite work do you have in the collection?

It’s impossible to pick just one out of our nearly 6,000 works today. Not surprisingly some of my enduring favorites are works by artists that I studied at length over the course of exhibition projects. Back in 2002, I had the pleasure of working on a Bonnard exhibition with former senior curator Beth Turner, and then again in 2019 with the Nabi collection of Vicki and Roger Sant which included many works by the French artist. There are many glorious Bonnards among our notable holdings, though I have a soft spot for The Open Window. Bonnard makes us feel as though we are breathing in the scene before that window, moving figuratively between inside and outside. In characteristic form, the artist encourages us to discover activity at the periphery: the woman at far right resting on the chair with a black cat by her side. The shimmering patterns of color give a vitality to the work that has stood the test of time more than a century since its making.

Finding where the sky meets the sand with TASSC board member Hagir Elsheikh

2021-22 Sherman Fairchild Fellow Shiloah Coley speaks with author, advocate, and survivor Hagir Elsheikh, whose portrait is featured in Portraits of Resilience at Phillips@THEARC (on view through July 29).

Jonathan Banks, Hagir Elsheikh, Sudan, 2019, Photograph, Courtesy of the artist

Hagir Elsheikh chose an image of her daughters to be projected onto her portrait taken by Jonathan Banks as part of the ongoing photo series Portraits of Resilience. The photo series features images of survivors of torture from around the world who fled their home countries seeking safety, recovery, and political asylum.

The war in Ukraine draws attention from people all around the world with approximately 8 million people being internally displaced, and 6.5 million fleeing to seek refuge in other countries, according to the UN Refugee Agency. Yet refugees from the Global South fleeing humanitarian crises have not been met with nearly the same response as their Ukrainian counterparts. Prior to the war in Ukraine, 68 percent of people forcibly displaced worldwide came from just five countries—Syria, Venezuela, Afghanistan, South Sudan, and Myanmar—according to the UNHCR Global Trends 2020.

The girls sit, smiling, surrounded by an abundance of greenery in the photograph. Their mother grew up in a much more arid environment with seemingly never-ending expanses of sand that nearly touch the sky at the horizon. Hagir wouldn’t arrive in the US, the place her daughters now call home, until 2001.

Hagir grew up during a time when women were often treated as second class citizens in Sudan, in part, reinforced by Sharia Islamic law, which formally began in 1983. The Islamic code restricted the rights of women. What does she tell her daughters about her life and upbringing in Sudan? “Everything, everything,” said Elsheikh. For every stage of her childrens’ lives she communicates part of her own story. In reference to her eldest daughter, Hagir said, “Every stage of her life, she knew what it was like for me at that age and how it is now for kids in Sudan at that age.”

Elsheikh wrote about her experience as part of Portraits of Resilience: “I was one of a few women activists who spoke publicly for the Democratic forefront. I experienced what happens in the infamous ‘Ghost Houses’ of Sudan, where brutality and murder are commonplace. I fought for women and human rights which meant that I was often detained and beaten. I was only a girl when Bashir’s security forces hung me from a tree and beat me for 10 hours, then left my bloody body in front of my home. During college, I continued to be detained and tortured until my head was cracked open with a metal bar by the government militia.”

Since immigrating to the U.S. in 2001, Hagir has relentlessly shared her story with the hopes of improving the lives of Sudanese people and women who have suffered human rights atrocities and domestic violence abroad and in the U.S. She is now a successful business owner, talk show host, board member of multiple nonprofits, and continues to be an advocate and activist for women’s rights through her nonprofit, Tomorrow’s Smile, Inc. But it’s not the titles or accomplishments that define success for Hagir.

“Did I make someone happy today? Did I help someone? Did I make a difference? Did everything bad that happened to me make it better for someone else?” asks Hagir. “And if the answer is yes, then I’m good. If the answer is no, I’m going to look and see what can I do? What more can I do?”

While adapting to life in the U.S. Hagir found herself navigating the challenges and violence of an abusive relationship. The persecution and violence she has faced in both her native country and once she immigrated to the U.S. inspired her to start Tomorrow’s Smile, Inc., which assists mostly Arab-speaking immigrants who are victims of domestic violence.

The cover of Elsheikh’s autobiography Through Tragedy and Triumph: A Life Well Traveled, co-written with Tom Peasley

“I wanted to combine all those resources because as a domestic violence victim, you already have enough. You’re beaten, you’ve taken enough,” said Elsheikh. “And for you to navigate and try to figure out, ‘What do I need to do to get legal help? What do I need to do to get through this?’ It’s overwhelming so I wanted to take the burden off.”

Hagir chronicled her story in her autobiography Through Tragedy and Triumph: A Life Well Traveled, co-written with Tom Peasley. As a woman who has overcome incredible feats, she’s still in search of herself. In the opening chapter, she tells the story of a little girl, a young Hagir, who is out wandering the desert in search of “where the blue sky meets the sand.”

“I don’t know if I found myself yet or that area where the sand meets the clouds. I’m still in search of that,” said Hagir. “I’m still in search of who truly I am and that area, what it represents.” Perhaps that space between the sand and the sky is where we find ourselves.

Hagir’s book is available for purchase in the Phillips’s gift shop.